Sunday, August 18, 2013

Comparison of Jim and Dagny Taggart


Simply by the personalities of each of the Taggart siblings, one would never be able to assume they could run a railroad empire effectively.  Dagny is objective, simple, and direct while her brother Jim is evasive, indecisive, and begrudging.
      Upon readers first introduction, Jim Taggart immediately shows his seeming inability to make a direct decision while Dagny automatically conveys a sense of purpose from her personality. Jim tells Dagny that “Nothing is absolute” when she wants a simple “yes or no” answer. Jim was interested about the reactions Board and about Orren Boyle while Dagny was thinking only of making the tracks and money. Dagny dose what’s best for the future of the company and does not care about how others perceive her. It is not apparent until Owen Kellogg quit that Dagny has vulnerability.
 Dagny is not afraid of failure and will take responsibility for all of her actions. Jim makes excuses that he simply does not have the ability to change a situation. The thought of being out of control is almost uncomfortable to Dagny. When Owen Kellogg quit she lost all control because her simple and objective way of handling a situation could not be applied and she could not fathom a logical reason for his leaving.
Jim seems naïve, and his positivity for things to just fall into place without action is misplaced. He talks about his sister having no emotions yet he is thought of not having the humility to sit in coach. There’s a needed balance between the two siblings, the ability to make strong and difficult decisions, and another side to recognize other peoples feelings in the process.  

No comments:

Post a Comment